I used to use Honest Amish beard products and frankly, my wife and daughters were repulsed by the smell. I also found their beard balm to be too waxy.
I was skeptical to try something new, but took the risk as I was inspired by a recent trip to the smoky mountains. The sample pack is a great way to find out which scent suits you. All the scents were good, none were nasty. Before getting the sample pack, there were two scents I thought I would prefer based on description, but ended up picking a different favorite when the products arrived. I don't like wearing heavy cologne, but the Cumberland scent was my favorite, which surprised me. It was smooth and manly, and the beard balm is much softer than the Honest Amish product, which leaves The beard feeling softer. I highly recommend their products, and the owner Nate personally contacted me with questions about my order. Excellent customer service.